I tried to keep this a 1:1 rewrite with the same field names.
Nevertheless, some changes were made:
- exp_add_error and exp_rem_error are dropped. Those fields meant that
"./test-udev add <devpath>" actually succeeded, but symlinks were not
created, and exp_links was ignored and could contain bogus content.
Instead, exp_links and not_exp_links are adjusted to not contain
garbage and the tests check that "./test-udev add" succeeds and that
the links are as expected from exp_links and not_exp_links.
- cleanup was only used in one rule, and that rule was expected to fail,
so cleanup wasn't actually necessary. So the cleanup field and the
logic to call cleanup from individual tests is removed.
- a bunch of fields were set, but didn't seem to be connected to any
implementation: not_exp_name, not_exp_test.
e62acc3159 did a rewrite of some of the
tests and it seems that not_exp_test was added by mistake and
not_exp_name was left behind by mistake.
In Python, the field list is declared in the class, so it's harder to
assign an unused attribute. Those uses were converted to not_exp_links.
- in most rules, r"""…""" is used, so that escaping is not necessary.
- the logic to generate devices was only used in one place, and the
generator function also had provisions to handle arguments that were
never given. all_block_devs() is made much simpler.
- Descriptions that started with a capital letter were shortened
and lowercased.
- no special test case counting is done. pytest just counts the cases
(Rules objects).
- the output for failures is also removed. If something goes wrong, the
user can use pytest --pdb or such to debug the issue.
- perl version used a semaphore to manage udev runners, and would fork,
optionally wait a bit, and then start the runner. In the python
version, we just spawn them all and wait for them to exit. It's not
very convenient to call fork() from python, so instead the runner
was modified (in previous commit) to wait.
The test can be called as:
(cd build && sudo pytest -v ../test/udev-test.py)
sudo meson test -C build udev-test.py -v
I think this generally provides functionality that is close to the perl
version. It seems some of the checks are now more fully implemented.
Support for strace/gdb/valgrind is missing.
Runtime goes down: 8.36 s → 5.78 s.
Instead of /home/zbyszek/src/systemd-work/build/../src/xdg-autostart-generator/xdg-autostart-service.h:11,
print just src/xdg-autostart-generator/xdg-autostart-service.h:11.
This is a bit annoying that this requires so much verbosity, but the output
with the full names was too annoying.
The tests wants to call some workers with a delay. This implements the delay
directly in test-udev so that the caller can be simplified.
Note that the argument is to be used by the other test file, so this is
purposefully implemented in a simple way.
The previous error code -ERANGE is slightly ambiguous, and use more
specific one. This also drops unnecessary error handlings.
Follow-up for 754d8b9c33 and
e652663a04.
This retains the use of policy sessions instead of trial sessions
in most cases, based on the code comment that some TPMs do not
implement trial sessions correctly. However, it's likely that the
issue was not the TPMs, but our code's incorrect use of PolicyPCR
inside a trial session; we are not providing expected PCR values
with our call to PolicyPCR inside a trial session, but the spec
indicates that in a trial session, the TPM *may* return error if
the expected PCR value(s) are not provided. That may have been the
source of the original confusion about trial sessions.
More details:
https://github.com/systemd/systemd/pull/26357#pullrequestreview-1409983694
Also, future commits will replace the use of trial sessions with
policy calculations, which avoids the problem entirely.
The usage of PREFIX in this completion is mostly counter to the intended
usage of compsys in zsh. It is generally expected that completion code
provide the available completions and tags in that word position so that
compsys, with user configuration, can filter them to the appropriate set.
One egregious error caused by the usage of PREFIX here is the caching of
SYS_ALL_UNITS, which stored only the unit names prematurely filtered by
the completion prefix, affecting all future completions. For example,
$ systemctl cat nonsense<TAB>
might find no matching units if nonsense* has no matches, but now
$ systemctl cat <TAB>
will fail in all future completions even though every unit file
is a valid match, because the cached set has been erroneously filtered
by the last prefix.
